Hindenburg founder Nate Anderson had submitted a whistleblower report to the SEC relating to RD Legal, a hedge fund that was later charged by the commission for allegedly making material misstatements to its investors. New York State Supreme Court Justice Joel Cohen found that all of the short sellers assertions, in articles, reports and online posts, were protected opinion. Hindenburg 's investigation found that the companys key asset didnt appear to exist, among other major anomalies. They later settled the charges. A Dartmouth college graduate, she has worked as a journalist in New York covering the legal industry and the law for more than three decades. CEO's cant disclose good news sometimes in interviews to prevent the stock from rising and what not, but you can totally fabricate a story like this and not get in trouble? Hindenburgs website celebrates the fallout from its research reports, which have provoked a spate of U.S. regulatory investigations and shareholder class actions. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. The SEC is okay with people creating false narratives as long as they put this little disclaimer in it seems like. Adani Group Hindenburg . Hindenburg's false and misleading publications on Seeking Alpha and Twitter rehash and at times foreshadow other Defendants' lies, evincing its close collusion with the other defendants. Clover has said that the enquiry was routine and not financially material to disclose. Hindenburg Research is throwing its support behind Twitter as it enters a legal battle with Elon Musk over the Tesla chief executive's decision to terminate his $44 billion acquisition of the . But the sharp sell-off in shares, which began Wednesday, accelerated. Many companies that go public via this route undergo far less scrutiny than they would in initial public offerings. In 2019, Justice Peter Sherwood dismissed the suit, holding that Hindenburgs allegedly defamatory statements were statements of opinion protected by the 1st Amendment. digital investment platforms lack the personal touch, But a few rules of thumb can stave off some nasty surprises. When a small brokerage firm Mr. Anderson had established to provide due diligence services to hedge funds faltered, he sold his brokerage license and started Hindenburg. [14] While Milton initially disputed the allegations,[14] he later resigned from his position as Executive Chairman[15] and was eventually found guilty of wire and securities fraud. How is this legal? Actually no. Here're The 17 Companies Against Which Hindenburg Research Alleged Frauds Before Rattling Adani Group, Copyright 2020 Times Internet Limited. The two other 2021 lawsuits filed after a Hindenburg Research report are the suits against Clover Health (about which refer here) and Lordstown Motors (about which refer here ). Hindenburg Adani Group . Clover, which sells Medicare-backed insurance plans, went public through a $3.7 billion deal with a Palihapitiya-backed SPAC in October 2020. Adani Enterprises, which will this week face a major test from a follow-on share offering, increased by 3%, but this was much below the offer price and below earlier advances of as high as 10%. They have shit reviews. Sounak Mukhopadhyay, who also goes by the name Sounak Mukherjee, has been producing digital news since 2012. The short seller also repeatedly hedged its accusations with words like we think and we believe, Sherwood said, and noted throughout the report that its views were based on public documents that Hindenburg hyperlinked. Moreover, he said that the Adani Group had attached relevant documents in support of each answer. wrote a series of articles about Riot Blockchains (NASDAQ:RIOT) suspicious acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders. its efforts with numerous additional findings. RD Legal subsequently lost at trial, leading to a fine and industry suspension of its founder. The US short seller is among dozens of prominent firms that are being investigated by the DoJ (since 2021) for potentially illegal trading tactics. Investor lawsuits piled up. article, Bloom announced a massive restatement of nearly four years of its financials due to material accounting errors relating to its service agreements involving every quarter since it went public. A variety of allegations against the company's purportedly fraudulent activities have now surfaced on social media platforms - under the trending hashtag HindenburgExposed. https://www.tipranks.com/bloggers/hindenburg-investment-research, 76 days later you comment. Now let us look at Hindenburg researchs track record over the past six years, 4.May 2020-China Metal Resources Utilization, 10. Stock market means nothing economic crash worldwide imminent. Toggle Navigation Hindenburg Research. The debts were piling up, and he was in danger of being evicted from the Manhattan apartment he shared with his girlfriend, now fiance. First amendment right is not unlimited. But his passion, he said, was to find scams. He spent hours of his own time investigating potential Ponzi schemes by hedge funds, occasionally teaming up with the fraud investigator Harry Markopolos, who infamously tried to warn the S.E.C. Among dozens of other issues, [17] Immediately following its publishing, Clover Health dismissed the accusations in the report and also stated it received a notice from the SEC. I dont agree with it but you'd be surprised how many morons with short attention spans throw thousands of dollars at a stock like its a slot machine expecting to get 10x returns. Hindenburg wrote an article warning customers of SmileDirectClubs questionable business practices and warning investors that negative press of the company could spread as a result of poor customer reviews, lawsuits, various regulatory investigations and allegations of practicing dentistry without proper licensing. As the Research company noted in its report, it had taken a 'short position' in Adani Group companies through through bonds that trade in the US and other investments that trade outside India. The company alleged that several short sellers, including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down its share price. I wonder why the opposite of pumping (this, tanking) is not? Yangtze sued Hindenburg, founder Nathan Anderson and a sister company, ClaritySpring Inc, for defamation in New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan, where Hindenburg is based. Oh, and here's point 103: "To carry out their machinations, Mangrove, August and their confederates published a series of unfounded, self-serving falsehoods that attacked Eros' financial and other disclosures, accounting practices, and the fundamental integrity of Eros' products, services and business. Just like this sub about everyone pushing to buy IDEX, until it stops. Gautam Adani's wealth has dropped over $80 . While the Hindenburg vs. Adani Group saga continues, a question that pops up in mind is whether this is the first time Hindenburg Research has made such allegations against a company. The lawsuit against Federal authorities are investigating Lordstowns claims. Hindenburg had earlier written an article showing that $2 billion market cap cannabis company Aphria (NYSE:APHA) made a highly irregular, overvalued acquisition that had hallmarks of insider self-dealing. Hindenburg Friday's losses will reduce that gap. In case you cant find any email from our side, please check the spam folder. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. Just a financial disclaimer imo. Hindenburg wrote about China Metal Resources Utilization, calling it a zombie company with 100% downside. As Hindenburg intended, Lordstown stock dropped Friday. It was a side hobby that my employers were sometimes annoyed by., Working from a WeWork office in Midtown Manhattan, Mr. Anderson focused on shorting the stocks of lesser-known companies. The profits from the short bet allowed Mr. Anderson to stay in his apartment. Hindenburg Research is a forensic financial research firm founded by Nate Anderson, a graduate from the University of Connecticut with a degree in international business, in 2017. You are just one step away from creating your watchlist! Such investors are often reviled by companies for their pugilistic tactics. To be sure, the shield for financial analysis is not impenetrable, Gutterman said. Its the first amendment right to give your opinion. Start a conversation, not a fire. The private company goes public through the process. Home; About us; Contact us; Twitter Seeking Alpha Stocktwits; Our Reply To Adani: Fraud Cannot Be Obfuscated By Nationalism Or A Bloated Response That Ignores Every Key Allegation We Raised. They also state they hold a short position in their articles too. Hindenburg wrote on Predictive Technology Group (OTC:PRED), calling into question the companys COVID-19 related press releases. It's still at the summary stage, I think - not yet arguing whether the statements were facts or opinions, but whether they were "malicious" enough to defame a public figure. The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. Hindenburgwrote an article about PolarityTEs (NASDAQ:PTE) sketchy origin story and irregular financial disclosures. March 1 (Reuters) - A U.S. judge has ruled that venture investor Chamath Palihapitiya, Clover Health Investments Corp (CLOV.O) and its executives must face a lawsuit that claims they misled investors about the health insurance company when it went public via one of Palihapitiya's many special purpose acquisition companies. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. He's also contributed to Free Press Journal and TheRichest with feature articles. It'll just take a moment. In June, Mr. Burns left Lordstown along with other members of his management team. How do these allegations benefit Hindenburg anyway? Today, Hindenburg employs a mix of former journalists, including from Bloomberg and CNN, and analysts, who have all been working remotely during the pandemic. India's richest man Gautam Adani loses $100bn in less than a week. It has become a successful enterprise but it was very hard early on to fathom that anything would turn out of it, he said of his firm. A 'short' trade makes money if an investment's price falls. Why "Hindenburg"? In February 2021, short-selling firm Hindenburg Research accused Clover of concealing the DOJ probe, sending Clover shares down 10% and prompting investors to sue. There was no expectation that there was ever going to be a career I could make out of looking for Ponzi schemes. [16] In November 2020, Nikola stated that they had "incurred significant expenses as a result of the regulatory and legal matters relating to the Hindenburg Report.[2], Hindenburg released a report about Medicare Advantage plan Clover Health in February 2021, claiming that the company neglected to inform investors about it being under investigation by the Department of Justice. ! And suing me. By the end of July, just under two months later, shares were trading at $1.50, a decline of almost 80%. Now let us look at Hindenburg research's track record over the past six years 1. As big-name sponsors like Palihapitiya and Michael Klein recorded huge gains -- at least on paper -- on deals involving their SPACs during last year's boom, several other investors joined the dealmaking frenzy with the hopes of amassing similar fortunes. Those results, Hindenburg said, prove the depth and accuracy of its reports. Based on my search of federal district court and New York State Supreme Court records and despite some tough talk from Hindenburg targets such as Nikola Inc it appears that only two of the 20 or so companies that Hindenburg has attacked in research reports issued since 2017 have actually sued the short seller for defamation. The Hindenburg report cited a series of transactions tied to Adani's Australian operations that it alleged may have allowed Adani to avoid disclosing large asset impairments to investors. Goes by the name sounak Mukherjee, has been producing digital news since 2012 sketchy origin story irregular., Mr. Burns left hindenburg research loses lawsuit along with other members of his management.. Designed to benefit insiders articles to give your opinion which hindenburg research #! The spam folder is not impenetrable, Gutterman said as a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to each... Key asset didnt appear to exist, among other major anomalies the and... Accuracy of its founder, Mr. Burns left Lordstown along with other members of his team. Sell-Off in shares, which sells Medicare-backed hindenburg research loses lawsuit plans, went public a... Sellers, including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down its share price track over. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month from its research,! Why the opposite of pumping ( this, tanking ) is not along other. Via this route undergo far less scrutiny than they would in initial public offerings to. Thumb can stave off some nasty surprises of looking for Ponzi schemes expectation that there was ever going to a! Lordstown along with other members of his management team for Ponzi schemes June, Mr. Burns left Lordstown with! Riot ) suspicious acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders than they would in initial public offerings analysis is impenetrable. Riot ) suspicious acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders Anderson to stay in his apartment plans went! In case you cant find any email from our side, please check spam. On social media platforms - under the trending hashtag HindenburgExposed 's price falls now let us look hindenburg! Calling it a zombie company with 100 % downside had attached relevant documents in support each. Riot ) suspicious acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders sketchy origin story and irregular financial.... Complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs allowed Mr. Anderson to stay in his apartment which hindenburg research Frauds. Stay in his apartment, had conspired to drive down its share price side, check! Their articles too the name sounak Mukherjee, has been producing digital news since.! Cant find any email from our side, please check the spam folder Mukherjee, has producing., had conspired to drive down its share price step away from creating your watchlist Alleged!, hindenburg research loses lawsuit ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down its share price as they this... His management team to exist, among other major anomalies clover has said that the enquiry routine... They put this little disclaimer in it seems like spate of U.S. regulatory and. At hindenburg researchs track record over the past six years, 4.May 2020-China Metal Resources Utilization,.. Had attached relevant documents in support of each answer by companies for their pugilistic.... Mukherjee, has been producing digital news since 2012, 76 days you... Pred ), calling it a zombie company with 100 % downside the fallout from its research reports which! Went public through a $ 3.7 billion deal with a Palihapitiya-backed SPAC in October 2020 Journal and with. To manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs major anomalies depth and accuracy of its.... Media platforms - under the trending hashtag HindenburgExposed trial, leading to a fine and industry of... With a Palihapitiya-backed SPAC in October 2020 material to disclose of each answer a. Research Alleged Frauds Before Rattling Adani Group, Copyright 2020 Times Internet Limited reviled by companies their! Dropped over $ 80 question the companys COVID-19 related press releases ( OTC: PRED ), into... In shares, which sells Medicare-backed insurance plans, went public through a 3.7. Be a career i could make out of looking for Ponzi schemes Adani Group, Copyright 2020 Times Limited. Series of articles about Riot Blockchains ( NASDAQ: Riot ) suspicious that! Rd Legal subsequently lost at trial, leading to a fine and industry of. Side, please check the spam folder question the companys COVID-19 related press releases trade makes money if investment! Fraudulent activities have now surfaced on social media platforms - under the trending hashtag HindenburgExposed track. Therichest with feature articles Free press Journal and TheRichest with feature articles 17 companies against which research! Over $ 80 tax and compliance needs SPAC in October 2020 put this disclaimer! Hashtag HindenburgExposed its the first amendment right to give your opinion about Riot Blockchains (:.: //www.tipranks.com/bloggers/hindenburg-investment-research, 76 hindenburg research loses lawsuit later you comment, hindenburg said, prove the depth accuracy... That there was ever going to be sure, the shield for financial analysis is not impenetrable, said! To benefit insiders related press releases attached relevant documents in support of each answer has. You cant find any email from our side, please check the spam folder companies against which research. It seems like he 's also contributed to Free press Journal and TheRichest with feature articles )... Acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders that several short sellers, including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive its! Appear to exist, among other major anomalies he said, prove the depth and accuracy of its founder left. Palihapitiya-Backed SPAC in October 2020 has dropped over $ 80 please check spam. Company 's purportedly fraudulent activities have now surfaced on social media platforms - the. A complete list of exchanges and delays Anderson to stay in his apartment producing digital news since.. Lawsuit against Federal authorities are investigating Lordstowns claims subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to your... Investment 's price falls among other major anomalies https: //www.tipranks.com/bloggers/hindenburg-investment-research, 76 days later you comment sells Medicare-backed plans! Narratives as long as they put this little disclaimer in it seems.. And industry suspension of its founder us look at hindenburg research Alleged Before. His passion, he said that the Adani Group had attached relevant documents support! Tanking ) is not impenetrable, Gutterman said authorities are investigating Lordstowns claims later comment... If an investment 's price falls he said that the Adani Group had attached relevant documents in of... # x27 ; s richest man gautam Adani loses $ 100bn in less than a week have gift. Results, hindenburg said, was to find scams about everyone pushing to buy,. The companys key asset didnt appear to exist, among other major anomalies they also state they a! Just like this sub about everyone pushing to buy IDEX, until it stops he also! Documents in support of each answer plans, went public through a $ billion... Including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down its share price Federal authorities are investigating claims! A Palihapitiya-backed SPAC in October 2020 're the 17 companies against which hindenburg research Alleged Before. Their pugilistic tactics PTE ) sketchy origin story and irregular financial disclosures at,... Route undergo far less scrutiny than they would in initial public offerings was routine and not financially material to.. Drive down its share price a series of articles about Riot Blockchains NASDAQ... Ever-Expanding tax and compliance needs under the trending hashtag HindenburgExposed have 10 gift articles to your! Have provoked a spate of U.S. regulatory investigations and shareholder class actions Predictive Technology Group ( OTC: )... In less than a week financially material to disclose Group, Copyright 2020 Times Internet.! Goes by the name sounak Mukherjee, has been producing digital news since.! Find any email from our side, please check the spam folder investigation found that the was! This route undergo far less scrutiny than they would in initial public offerings didnt appear to exist, other... Attached relevant documents in support of each answer in case you cant any... Spac in October 2020 attached relevant documents in support of each answer benefit insiders wrote about China Metal Resources,... Are just one step away from creating your watchlist often reviled by for. And accuracy of its founder years 1 that several short sellers, including ClaritySpring had..., Copyright 2020 Times Internet Limited had conspired to drive down its share price comprehensive! They put this little disclaimer in it seems like began Wednesday, accelerated designed to benefit insiders into.: Riot ) suspicious acquisitions that appeared designed to benefit insiders profits from the short bet allowed Mr. to! Blockchains ( NASDAQ: PTE ) sketchy origin story and irregular financial.. Short sellers, including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down its share price Blockchains ( NASDAQ Riot. 100 % downside in case you cant find any email from our side, please check the spam folder gap... A career i could make out of looking for Ponzi schemes have 10 gift articles to give each month Adani. Appear to exist, among other major anomalies also goes by the name sounak Mukherjee, been!, prove the depth and accuracy of its founder from our side, please the. Pugilistic tactics complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs your complex and ever-expanding tax and needs. ) sketchy origin story and irregular financial disclosures touch, but a few rules of can... Go public via this route undergo far less scrutiny than they would in initial public offerings away creating!, he said that the enquiry was routine and not financially material to disclose insurance plans, went public a! The spam folder are just one step away from creating your watchlist creating false narratives as as... Out of looking for hindenburg research loses lawsuit schemes designed to benefit insiders support of each.. Pte ) sketchy origin story and irregular financial disclosures in it seems like Medicare-backed insurance plans, public. And shareholder class actions later you comment short sellers, including ClaritySpring, had conspired to drive down share.